welcome new england cheese company fans! consider subscribing
for the last few months ma and i have been adding to what seems like a massive amount of dairy in our lives with a cow share from hampshire farms. while it might seem ridiculous for us to buy milk when we can get so much milk from the goat’s at cfa, we have been dreaming for years of making our own butter. goat milk is naturally homogenized which means trying to get cream from goat milk requires a cream separator, something which would set us back a few hundred dollars. it’s quite a bit cheaper to just buy some raw cow’s milk.
separating the cream from cow’s milk is a pretty simple task as the cream settles to the top quite quickly. most of the time we just suck the cream off with a turkey baster, add some buttermilk and culture it. once it’s sat out at room temperature for 24 hours the cultured cream is quite solid, it can easily be spooned off. you can also let it culture on its own, but you have less control over flavor and it tends to be pretty funky. if you don’t bother with culturing then you have sweet cream butter.
after weeks of culturing, skimming and scooping cream we are left with a good amount of cream.
once all the cream is accumulated it’s time to make butter. we could use some old-fashioned churn, but we were given a kitchen aid when we got married and ma looks for every opportunity to use it, plus sticking a bunch of cream in the kitchen aid and just letting it go is so much easier than a churn. make sure that the cream is cold as is the bowl on the kitchen aid, as it seems to help.
the thing i find most challenging in butter making is the wait. it seems to take forever for the cream to turn into butter – so stop fretting, and do something else while you wait, it can take as long as 45 minutes. wash those dishes you have been putting off.
once the butter has formed nicely, it’s time to remove the butter milk – the liquid that separates from the solids. we use some cheese cloth or actually i think in this case we are using butter muslin – how appropriate, to drain off the butter milk.
save that buttermilk, it can be used for all kinds of cooking and baking uses. even though the butter looks like it is free of buttermilk there is still some left inside, and if allowed to remain it would mean the butter could turn rancid from too much moisture. so you must wash out the buttermilk with cold water.
the butter is soft and the heat of you hands makes it even softer so throw a few ice cubes in the water to help it stiffen up. massage it in a couple of changes of water and it should be in good shape.
once it’s done you can put it into molds, should you have any, or just wrap it in wax paper and form into logs. put it in the fridge and it should harden up into nice yellow lovely butter, so good you will want to use it on everything. cultured butter has a more sour flavor, almost cheesy from the culturing. it can be a little shocking if you are not ready for it, but once you are used to it, it’s hard to go back to sweet cream butter.